BWCAW Research, Publications and Articles

In 2022, the U.S. Forest Service (Forest Service) Superior National Forest (SNF) began a new effort to engage individuals and groups with interests in recreation, advocacy, or commercial use in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW or Wilderness) in exploring current issues, concerns, and possibilities for collaboration with SNF. To support this initiative, SNF asked the John S. McCain III National Center for Environmental Conflict Resolution (National Center), a program of the Morris K. Udall and Stewart L. Udall Foundation (Udall Foundation), to conduct confidential assessment discussions with a wide variety of interested individuals. The Udall Foundation is an independent, nonpartisan Federal agency of the Executive Branch.

The National Center conducted the assessment from December 2022 – May 2023. The primary goal was to assess the feasibility of SNF convening a multi-party collaborative effort to strengthen communication and collaboration surrounding BWCAW management challenges. The National Center invited more than 250 individuals to participate in this assessment effort. That outreach resulted in discussions with 100 individuals representing 66 distinct groups of cooperators, outfitters, guides, partners, visitors, academics, non-government organizations, local governments, and Federal, State, and County staff.1 Information obtained was then analyzed for prevalent topics and themes that emerged frequently or in- depth during the discussions. Discussions explored personal views on Wilderness management, communication and education needs, and the value in establishing ongoing collaboration between SNF and interested parties.

This assessment report first highlights participant perspectives on the needs for collaboration and what that might require to be successful. It then explores challenges and opportunities to improve management of the BWCAW and ideas for how SNF might strengthen its communication, coordination, and educational efforts. Participants focused on a variety of management and communication issues, including visitor use patterns, campsite and trail maintenance, how to prevent and address “Leave No Trace” violations, permit system challenges, access to and availability of opportunities to experience the BWCAW, motorized and non-motorized use issues, current and future environmental impacts to the BWCAW, and several issues outside of the BWCAW that could cause impact inside the BWCAW. Participants pointed to the importance of SNF building strong relationships with local partners, including individual residents, communities, and Tribes. Participants also highlighted the need to update education and resource materials that encourage visitors to recreate responsibly.

The assessment concludes with overarching recommendations for SNF to consider. Most participants support the idea of purposeful and focused collaboration to increase understanding and to explore possibilities to preserve, protect, and improve a unique wilderness area they all care deeply about. Based on both participant interest and SNF’s desire to engage interested parties, the National Center recommends SNF move forward with forming a collaborative group or other forms of sustained public engagement. As a next step, the National Center will meet with the SNF leadership team to discuss the overall assessment results, recommendations on key issues, and potential actions for further engagement with interested parties.

BWCAW Situational Assessment Report and Recommendations 2023 (pdf)

BWCAW Situational Assessment Report FAQ (pdf)

A GIS-based approach was used to depict how threats to wilderness character vary in extent and magnitude across the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. Based on the interagency strategy to monitor wilderness character, Keeping It Wild: An Interagency Strategy for Monitoring Wilderness Character Across the National Wilderness Preservation System (Landres et al. 2008a), 53 locally relevant measures were identified by the project core team to capture impacts to the five qualities of wilderness character. These measures were depicted using a variety of spatial datasets, which were normalized using a common relative scale such that disparate metrics could be analyzed together. Each measure was “weighted” by the project core team to reflect its relative impact to wilderness character. Maps generated for each of the weighted measures were then added accumulatively to create a combined map delineating the overall spatial pattern and variation of threats to wilderness character across the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. This combined map depicts a wilderness that has not been substantially impacted by threats, with the highest quality wilderness character primarily found away from entry points and travel routes, especially in areas with fewer and smaller lakes; in contrast, the lowest quality wilderness character was highly correlated with lakes that allow motorized use, especially those that are wilderness entry points. The map products presented in this report provide managers with a tool to better understand the extent and magnitude of threats to wilderness character, holistically evaluate tradeoffs associated with decisions and actions in wilderness, and ultimately improve wilderness stewardship.

Mapping Wilderness Character in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (pdf)

The purpose of this study was to determine trends in use and user characteristics at the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. Based on data from 1969, 1991, and 2007, the average age of visitors has increased significantly, education levels have increased, and visitors remain predominantly male. Visitors in 2007 report seeing twice as many groups since 1961 and 1991, but the number of encounters are not exceeding expectations. Findings emerged related to gender ratios and evaluating resource conditions. These findings may need further investigation and future management action to provide opportunities for meaningful wilderness experiences while protecting wilderness character.

The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness: Examining Changes in Use, Users, and Management Challenges (pdf)

Selected articles regarding aspects of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness

Sustainable campsite management in protected areas: A study of long-term ecological changes on campsites in the boundary waters canoe area wilderness, Minnesota, USA

Holly Eaglestona,∗, Jeffrey L. Marionba Virginia Tech, 310 W. Campus Dr., Blacksburg, VA 24061, United States USDI

A Synthesis of the Economic Values of Wilderness

Thomas P. Holmes, J.M. Bowker, Jeffrey Englin, Evan Hjerpe, John B. Loomis, Spencer Phillips, and Robert Richardson

Early applications of wilderness economic research demonstrated that the values of natural amenities and commodities produced from natural areas could be measured in commensurate terms. To the surprise of many, the economic values of wilderness protection often exceeded the potential commercial values that might resultfrom resource extraction. Here, the concepts and tools used in the economic analysis of wilderness are described, and the wilderness economic literature is reviewed with a focus on understanding trends in use, value, and economic impacts. Although our review suggests that each of these factors is trending upward, variations in research methods plus large gaps in the literature limit understanding of long-run trends. However, as new data on wilderness use, visitor origins, and spatially referenced features of landscapes are becoming increasingly available, more robust economic analysis of both onsite and offsite wilderness economic values and impacts is now becoming possible.

Celebrating the 50th Anniversary of the Wilderness Act

The National Wilderness Conference Proceedings | Albuquerque, New Mexico | October 15-19, 2014

Naturalness” in Designated Wilderness: Long-Term Changes in Non-Native Plant Dynamics on Campsites, Boundary Waters, Minnesota

Holly A. Eagleston and Jeffrey L. Marion

Wilderness areas in the United States are preserved for their untrammeled naturalness and opportunities for unconfined recreation. The Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness has these qualities, but long-term recreation visitation pressures on campsites can cause significant ecological changes. This article explores changes on campsites, specifically examining non-native plant ecology over 3 decades.

Structural Constraints to Wilderness Impacts on Visitation and Experience

Ingrid E. Schneider, Sierra l. Schroeder, and Ann Schwaller

A significant research body on recreation constraints exists, but wilderness constraints research is limited. Like other recreationists, wilderness visitors likely experience a number of constraints, factors that limit leisure preference formation or participation and enjoyment. This project explored how visitors’ experiences with and in wilderness are constrained, and examined responses to those constraints. International Journal of Wilderness

Visitor Attitudes Toward Fire and Wind Disturbances in Wilderness

Robert G. Dvorak and Erin D. Small

Abstract: This study examines visitor attitudes across the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness regarding the effects of natural disturbances on visitor planning and wilderness conditions. Visitors were intercepted at entry points and permit distribution locations during 2007. Results suggest that respondents were aware of recent wind and fire disturbances. Few respondents reported that these events had affected trip plans. Evidence of natural disturbances was evaluated as desirable or indifferent conditions in wilderness. Further investigation of these events related to travel patterns and perceptions may help understand their impacts on visitor use and behavior.