Value Analysis Presentation, Allison Ranger Station, Ochoco National Forest: Slide 35

Criteria	Alt.#1—New triplex at old campground		Alt.#2—Rehab 3-C buildings		Alt.#3—New Buildings at 4-corners site		Alt.#4—Dispatch crews from Burns		Alt. #5—Place modular building at old campground
Measure	Alt.#1—New triplex at old campground		Alt.#2—Rehab 3-C buildings		Alt.#3—New Buildings at 4-corners site		Alt.#4—Dispatch crews from Burns		Alt. #5—Place modular building at old campground
Impact to Historic Values	3	45	5	90	1	0	1	0	3	45
Enhances 5<----->0 Degrades	2	45	4	90	0	0	0	0	2	45
Impact to Recreation Values	3	15	4	30	2	0	2	0	3	15
Enhances 5<----->0 Degrades	1	15	2	30	0	0	0	0	1	15
Livability for Crews	5	70	4	60	4	60	5	70	4	60
Desirable 5<----->0 Not preferred	1	70	0	60	0	60	1	70	0	60
Initial Cost	$802m	10	$694m	20	$918m	0	$0	80	$573m	30
Dollars ($)	$116	10	$224	20	$0	0	$918	80	$345	30
Life Cycle Cost	$795m	2	$687m	11	$816m	0	$234m	50	$638m	15
Present Net Worth ($)	$21	2	$129	11	$0	0	$582	50	$178	15
Opportunity to Correct H/S-Environ.	3	50	5	100	1	0	1	0	3	50
Best 5<----->0 Poor	2	50	4	100	0	0	0	0	2	50
Totals	192		403		60		200		215