Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Effects of tree retention and woody biomass removal on bird and small mammal communities

Formally Refereed
Authors: Alexis R. Grinde, Robert A. Slesak, A.W. D'Amato, B.P. Palik
Year: 2020
Type: Scientific Journal
Station: Northern Research Station
Source: Forest Ecology and Management


Contemporary forest management is increasingly focused on maintaining ecosystem function and services including biodiversity conservation. As a result, harvest guidelines related to retention of live trees and woody biomass (fine and coarse residue arising from harvesting) have been developed to provide benefits for wildlife, but there is much uncertainty on the effectiveness of these guidelines depending on stage of succession, retention levels, and focal taxa. We used an operational-scale, fully replicated factorial experiment to determine the effects of both tree retention (none, dispersed, aggregated) and woody residue harvesting (no removal, 20% retention, all removed) on breeding bird and small mammal communities in aspen forests 7–8 years after harvest. Bird community metric responses showed a clear and consistent positive response to tree retention; both tree retention configurations resulted in higher total abundance, increased diversity, and higher species richness compared to stands with no tree retention. There was no difference in community metrics between the retention configurations and no evidence that early successional species were negatively affected by tree retention. Total abundance of small mammals was lower in clear-cuts compared to tree retention treatments; moreover, clear-cut stands had lower species diversity compared to stands with the aggregated tree retention. There were limited effects of biomass harvest treatments on small mammal communities, likely because actual biomass removal was much lower than experimental targets. Overall, our results provide conclusive evidence on the continued benefits of tree retention on wildlife communities seven and eight years post-harvest in regenerating aspen forests.


Green tree, Avian, Biodiversity, Populus tremuloides, Ecological forestry


Grinde, Alexis R.; Slesak, Robert A.; D'Amato, A.W.; Palik, B.P. 2020. Effects of tree retention and woody biomass removal on bird and small mammal communities. Forest Ecology and Management. 465: 118090. 9 p.