A rigorous test of the accuracy of USGS digital elevation models in forested areas of Oregon and Washington.Author(s): Ward W. Carson; Stephen E. Reutebuch
Source: In: Volume 1 surveying and cartography: 1997 ACSM/ASPRS Annual convention and exposition technical paper; Seattle, WA; April 7-10, 1997: 133-143
Publication Series: Scientific Journal (JRNL)
PDF: Download Publication (503 KB)
DescriptionA procedure for performing a rigorous test of elevational accuracy of DEMs using independent ground coordinate data digitized photogrammetrically from aerial photography is presented. The accuracy of a sample set of 23 DEMs covering National Forests in Oregon and Washington was evaluated. Accuracy varied considerably between eastern and western parts of Oregon and Washington, and to a lesser extent, by DEM production method.
The elevational root mean square errors (P, SE) computed from independent ground data for DEMs produced using the line-trace method were on average 4 times larger than RMSEs published by the USGS for both eastside and westside DEMs. Computed RMSEs for all westside line-trace DEMs exceeded 7m; whereas, 80°,/o of eastside line-trace DEMs had computed RMSEs of 7m or less.
Published RMSEs of eastside DEMs produced using the photogrammetric technique agreed within I m on average with RMSEs computed from independent ground data; and, all tested eastside photogrammetric DEMs had RMSEs of 7m or less. Published RMSEs for westside photogrammetric DEMs were on average 4m lower than the computed RMSEs; and, 75% of computed RMSEs exceeded 7m.
Although published RMSEs for line-trace DEMs were on average lower than published RMSEs for photogrammetric DEMs, the RMSEs computed from independent data sets did not follow this pattern: photogrammetric DEMs had lower RMSEs than line-trace DEMs. In addition, published RMSEs of photogrammetric DEMs had a much higher correlation (r2=0.64) than did line-trace DEMs (r2=0.36) with RMSEs computed from independent test data.
- Visit PNW's Publication Request Page to request a hard copy of this publication.
- We recommend that you also print this page and attach it to the printout of the article, to retain the full citation information.
- This article was written and prepared by U.S. Government employees on official time, and is therefore in the public domain.
CitationCarson, Ward W.; Reutebuch, Stephen E. 1997. A rigorous test of the accuracy of USGS digital elevation models in forested areas of Oregon and Washington. In: Volume 1 surveying and cartography: 1997 ACSM/ASPRS Annual convention and exposition technical paper; Seattle, WA; April 7-10, 1997: 133-143
- Modelling topographic potential for erosion and deposition using GIS
- Augmentation of traditional forest inventory and airborne laser scanning with unmanned aerial systems and photogrammetry for forest monitoring
- Effects of model spatial resolution on ecohydrologic predictions and their sensitivity to inter-annual climate variability
XML: View XML