Skip to Main Content
Sources and magnitude of sampling error in redd counts for bull troutAuthor(s): Jason B. Dunham; Bruce Rieman
Source: North American journal of fisheries management. 21(2): 343-352
Publication Series: Miscellaneous Publication
PDF: View PDF (106 KB)
DescriptionMonitoring of salmonid populations often involves annual redd counts, but the validity of this method has seldom been evaluated. We conducted redd counts of bull trout Salvelinus confluentus in two streams in northern Idaho to address four issues: (1) relationships between adult escapements and redd counts; (2) interobserver variability in redd counts; (3) sources of interobserver variability; and (4) temporal and spatial variation in spawning activity. We found that estimated adult escapements and redd counts were strongly correlated on a logarithmic scale, but both sources of data probably contained large estimation or observation errors. In particular, redd counts varied significantly among observers in replicate counting trials. Observer counts ranged between 28% and 254% of the best estimates of actual redd numbers. Counting errors included both omissions and false identifications. Correlations between counting errors and redd and habitat characteristics were highly variable and provided limited insights into potential causes of sampling error. Finally, we found significant spatial and temporal variability in spawning activity, which should be considered in establishing index areas for redd counts and the timing of counts. Our results suggest substantial improvements are needed to make redd counts and unbiased estimates of adult escapement more useful for population monitoring.
- You may send email to email@example.com to request a hard copy of this publication.
- (Please specify exactly which publication you are requesting and your mailing address.)
CitationDunham, Jason B.; Rieman, Bruce. 2001. Sources and magnitude of sampling error in redd counts for bull trout. North American journal of fisheries management. 21(2): 343-352
KeywordsSalvelinus confluentus, sampling, monitoring, redds, spawning, streams, Idaho
- Fine-scale characteristics of fluvial bull trout redds and adjacent sites in Rapid River, Idaho, 1993-2007
- Comparison of day snorkeling, night snorkeling, and electrofishing to estimate bull trout abundance and size structure in a second-order Idaho stream
- Capture, marking, and enumeration of juvenile bull trout and cutthroat trout in small, low-conductivity streams
XML: View XML