Skip to Main Content
Assessing ecosystem restoration alternatives in eastern deciduous forests: the view from belowgroundAuthor(s): Ralph E.J. Boerner; Adam T. Coates; Daniel A. Yaussy; Thomas A. Waldrop
Source: Restoration Ecology, Vol. 16(3): 425-434
Publication Series: Scientific Journal (JRNL)
PDF: Download Publication (2.22 MB)
DescriptionBoth structural and functional approaches to restoration of eastern deciduous forests are becoming more common as recognition of the altered state of these ecosystems grows. In our study, structural restoration involves mechanically modifying the woody plant assemblage to a species composition, density, and community structure specified by the restoration goals. Functional restoration involves reintroducing dormant-season, low-severity fire at intervals consistent with the historical condition. Our approach was to quantify the effects of such restoration treatments on soil organic carbon and soil microbial activity, as these are both conservative ecosystem attributes and not ones explicitly targeted by the restoration treatments, themselves. Fire, mechanical thinning, and their combination all initially resulted in reduced soil organic C content, C:N ratio, and overall microbial activity (measured as acid phosphatase activity) in a study site in the southern Appalachian Mountains of North Carolina, but only the effect on microbial activity persisted into the fourth post-treatment growing season. In contrast, in a similar forest in the central Appalachian Plateau of Ohio, mechanical thinning resulted in increased soil organic C, decreased C:N ratio, and decreased microbial activity, whereas fire and the combination of fire and thinning did not have such effects. In addition, the effects in Ohio had dissipated prior to the fourth post-treatment growing season. Mechanical treatments are attractive in that they require only single entries; however, we see no indication that mechanical-structural restoration actually produced desired belowground changes. A single fire-based/functional treatment also offered little restoration progress, but comparisons with long-term experimental fire studies suggest that repeated entries with prescribed fire at intervals of 3-8 years offer potential for sustainable restoration.
- You may send email to email@example.com to request a hard copy of this publication.
- (Please specify exactly which publication you are requesting and your mailing address.)
- We recommend that you also print this page and attach it to the printout of the article, to retain the full citation information.
- This article was written and prepared by U.S. Government employees on official time, and is therefore in the public domain.
CitationBoerner, Ralph E.J.; Coates, Adam T.; Yaussy, Daniel A.; Waldrop, Thomas A. 2008. Assessing ecosystem restoration alternatives in eastern deciduous forests: the view from belowground. Restoration Ecology, Vol. 16(3): 425-434
Keywordsdeciduous forests, fire, microbial activity, restoration alternatives, soil organic carbon
- Ecosystem restoration treatments affect soil physical and chemical properties in Appalachian mixed oak forests
- Mechanical restoration of California mixed-conifer forests: does it matter which trees are cut?
- Soil nitrogen transformations under alternative management strategies in Appalachian forests
XML: View XML