Skip to Main Content
Estimating the Economic Value of Lethal Versus Nonlethal Deer Control in Suburban CommunitiesAuthor(s): J. Michael Bowker; David H. Newman; Robert J. Warren; David W. Henderson
Source: Society and Natural Resources, 16:143-l58, 2003
Publication Series: Miscellaneous Publication
PDF: View PDF (150 KB)
DescriptionNegative people/wildlife interaction has raised public interest in wildlife population control. We present a contingent valuation study of alternative deer control measures considered for Hilton Head Island, SC. Lethal control usig sharpshooters and nonlethal immuno-contraception techniques are evaluated. A mail-back survey was used to collect resident willingness-to-pay (WTP) information for reduced deer densities and consequent property damage. Residents are unwilling to spend more for the nonlethal alternative. The estimated WTP appears theoretically consistent as increasing levels of abatement for both lethal and nonlethal alternatives demonstrate diminishing marginal benefits. Over 60% of respondents bid zero regardless of control measure, suggesting a referendum would fail. However, only half of these zero bidders expressed no problem with deer, while the other half bid zero because of distaste for the control alternative, safety concerns, or doubt about effectiveness. Inclusion of these responses as legitimate zero bids depressed mean WTP estimates from 22 to 31%.
- You may send email to firstname.lastname@example.org to request a hard copy of this publication.
- (Please specify exactly which publication you are requesting and your mailing address.)
CitationBowker, J. Michael.; Newman, David H.; Warren, Robert J.; Henderson, David W. 2003. Estimating the Economic Value of Lethal Versus Nonlethal Deer Control in Suburban Communities. Society and Natural Resources, 16:143-l58, 2003
Keywordscontingent valuation, deer management, immuno-contraception, mail survey, protest bids, Tobit
- Modeling willingness to pay for land conservation easements: treatment of zero and protest bids and application and policy implications
- Economic value of ecosystem conservation in Japan: Reduction of starting point bias by bid effect function
- A comparison of cheap talk and alternative certainty calibration techniques in contingent valuation
XML: View XML